The Black Carnaby from Vegetarian Shoes UK looks like any pointy oxford you'd see on the runway. The difference is that this shoe is made from eco and animal-friendly vegetan, as opposed to someone's toxically-preserved skin.
One of our favorite shops, Alter, is having a big sale on everything fall 08. There are tons of animal-friendly options, and everything is up to 70% off! For example, this Spiewalk Cotton-Moleskin jacket with Thinsulate lining is only $155, and will keep you warm for the next four months!
Another great place to stop by is the new and imporved Sustainable NYC shop. They've got a cafe, now - with lots of veg options (not sure why everything isn't vegan). Also make sure to check out their online store.